10 Ways to Spot Valuable Vintage Dishware

Editor’s Note: This story originally appeared on The Penny Hoarder.

There’s never been a better time to turn dishes into cash. Same goes for crystal, silver, and those figurines your grandmother loved.

It’s not because they are in high demand, but rather because the demand for formal dinnerware decreases each year.

Unlike other collectibles, Waterford and Wedgwood aren’t gaining value with age.

Still, some folks, mostly older ones, are looking to complete sets of china and crystal or replace broken pieces. And a smaller number of younger entertainers like to have some vintage pieces in their collection.

Depending on the pattern, condition and current supply and demand, you can make a few hundred dollars when you sell Nana’s china plates collection.

But, unless you have some of the more rare patterns that can fetch $1,000 a plate, don’t expect to get rich. What was sentimentally valuable china to your family may not be worth thousands of dollars.

You Might Get Lucky and Hit Big

“The question I hear most often when I give somebody a quote for what we’ll pay is ‘is that for all of it?’ ” said Larry Weitkemper, one of the owners of China Finders in St. Petersburg, Florida. “The demand is less. Prices are down.”

Someone with a five-piece place setting (dinner, salad and bread plates with cup and saucer) of Wedgwood may get around $40, Lennox about $25 and Mikasa around $20.

Resellers and dealers, however, may pay up to $1,000 for a Royal Copenhagen Flora Danica dinner plate, the golden ticket of pre-owned china.

China Finders, which stocks thousands of pieces of china and crystal in its 4,900-square-foot store, is one of about 50 independent resellers across the country.

A decade ago it had 14 employees buying and selling china, crystal and other collectibles. Today, four employees buy in person (by appointment only) then sell on their eBay store.

For people on the hunt for rare patterns, an internet search is likely the best way to find valued old dishes.

Pattern Prices at a Glance From Replacements Ltd. by Maker, Pattern, Item, and Sale Price*

• Franciscan, Desert Rose, Dinner plate, $39.99
• Fiesta, Evergreen 2007, Dinner plate, $79.95
• Lenox, Poppies on Blue, Dinner plate, $29.99
• Royal Copenhagen, Blue Fluted Plain, 9-inch serving bowl, $370
• Portmeirion, Botanic Garden, Crescent salad plate, $43.99
• Wedgwood, Runnymede Blue, Rim soup bowl, $89.95
• Herend, Chinese Bouquet (rust), Crescent salad plate, $60
• Dansk, Christianshavn Blue, Dinner plate (Portugal), $49.99
• Wedgwood, Nantucket Basketweave, Accent luncheon plate, $159.99
• Noritake; Rothschild, Ivory; Cup and saucer; $23.99

*These are list prices the public pays to purchase items. Replacements Ltd.’s payment to sellers depends on supply and demand at the time of transaction and is less than list price.

How to Sell to Replacements

Replacements Ltd., in McLeansville, North Carolina, is the largest buyer and seller of previously owned china, crystal and flatware with 450,000 different patterns listed in its database from antique china with floral patterns to highly valuable dessert plates.

It stocks new and preowned products in 500,000 square feet of warehouse space.

Its website offers very clear directions on how to find out what the company will pay for your china, glasswear, silver or other collectibles. If you know your pattern, submit the pattern name and your personal contact information via an electronic form.

Replacements will reply with what it’s paying for each piece of a pattern. Depending on the supply it has in the warehouse, it may be buying dinner plates, salt and pepper shakers, butter dishes and bowls in a pattern, for example, but no salad plates, cups and saucers or serving platters.

So a seller can tell exactly what Replacements will buy. Ship your pieces based on its packing instructions, and in a few weeks, a check arrives in your mailbox.

Dish Habits of Modern Newlyweds

Keith Winkler, media relations manager for the 40-year-old company, said while prices fluctuate greatly, fine china and crystal are still popular with a wide range of customers.

Again, many variables go into placing a value on it.

“It’s all about whether we stock that pattern or not and how easy it is to find it,” he said. “Some of it is also how popular it was when the pattern was introduced. Was it successful and continues to be sold in stores or was it extremely popular for a 10-year period of time and now it’s gone?”

He said they are seeing an increase in business from a younger demographic.

“A lot of them might have received their grandmother’s set and they are building on that for their bridal registry,” Winkler added.

Others are looking for their own china. In fact so many couples getting married were registering on Replacements’ website through Myregistry, came to the china dealer five years ago and asked to join forces on gift registries.

10 Things to Know If You’re Selling Old Dishes

• Patterns don’t gain value with age.
• Know the patterns that are most valuable.
• Know other popular patterns.
• Demand varies for extra pieces.
• Wine glasses are out, goblets are in.
• Gold trim can kill the sale.
• Shipping is costly.
• Country of origin counts.
• Limitations of Christmas china patterns.
• To eBay or not to eBay those porcelain dishes.

Trust the Pros

First you need to know if it’s antique and just because it’s old to you, doesn’t mean it’s a legit antique or has a lot of value. Antiques are generally at least 100 years old; newer older items are considered vintage. Look to a professional for help.

The market determines the prices so your dream of getting rich off a single item for thousands of dollars is likely just that. Still, there’s money to be had.

Our vintage china and glassware experts have done their research and here is their best advice for those of us surveying Nana’s china cabinet and trying to get past the floral bouquet in the middle of the plates.

These 10 tips can help you find the best value hiding on the shelves.

1. Patterns Don’t Gain Value With Age

“We have to buy something people are still using,” Weitkemper said.

Now, that doesn’t mean old patterns are necessarily not worth good money as long as they are still popular with current consumers. But they are just not like other collectibles such as coins that gain value as they age.

2. Know the Patterns That Are Most Valuable

• Herend: “Most patterns from Herend sell well,” Winkler said. A platter recently sold for $200 on eBay while a salad plate went for $100. Herend originated in Hungary in 1839 and its pieces are typified by fine floral patterns. The history of the manufacturer and the fine craftsmanship overrules the fact that many younger people don’t want fussy porcelain pieces.
• Royal Copenhagen Blue Fluted: A cup and saucer recently sold on eBay for $100 and a salad plate fetched the same price. “It’s a very high quality brand and it’s in high demand. It’s made really well,” according to Larry Weitkemper.
• Royal Copenhagen Flora Danica: This is about the most expensive player in the fine china reselling market. Two salad plates sold on eBay recently for $375 while a pickle dish sold for $500.

3. Know Other Popular Patterns

Replacements Ltd. lists its top selling patterns, which is a good indicator the valuable china is selling well on other sites, with dealers and individually. But that doesn’t mean they will always command top dollar.

“We may have a piece retailing for $50 but have a 10-year supply on hand and therefore we may not be purchasing it at all or would offer a nominal amount for the piece,” said Winkler.

Here are the links for:

4. Extra Pieces Vary in Demand

Butter dishes and salt and pepper sets are more sought after than spoon rests and coffee pots.

The current values reflect modern cooking habits, and the selling price and pattern don’t much matter. Many companies have produced these pieces and they can be found online and in antiques shops in abundance.

“Teapots hold their values better than coffee pots,” said Noah Weitkemper, one of the China Finders partners.

5. Wine Glasses Are Out, Goblets Are In

“Wine glasses are going out of style because they are too small in older patterns. (Consumers) use water goblets for wine,” Noah Weitkemper said.

Even baby boomers are likely to want glasses that can hold a larger pour. These days, a standard wine glass holds about 12 ounces and vintage wine glassware might be half of that.

The green-stemmed German wine glasses used for white wine are a good example of smaller capacity bowls, especially the older vintages.

6. Gold Trim Can Kill the Sale

The 20-year-olds and 30-year-olds — heck almost everyone — buying china today want to put their dishes in the microwave or dishwasher.

Washing individual pieces by hand isn’t going to fly no matter if the current value is affordable and even if they like the pattern. And reheating ramen in the microwave is standard these days.

The dishes have to fit the job, and just being valuable doesn’t cut it.

“Anything with gold trim can’t go in the dishwasher and it can’t go in the microwave. So they don’t want it,” Larry Weitkemper said.

Sorry, Nana. The Noritake vintage china is a no-go even though there’s enough old dishes to serve 12. That’s just more washing.

7. Shipping Is Costly

If selling to Replacements, you will pay for packing and shipping your china. That can cancel out or at least heavily cut into whatever profit you expect to make.

Consider this if you purchased good-condition china to resell. Always do your research first.

“A person really needs to consider all of that when they are wanting to sell. it’s going to be so expensive to ship,” Winkler said. “It might be better to donate it.”

Do some internet research or head to your local library to look for organizations that take donations of dishes, glassware and other pieces.

8. Country of Origin Counts

China and glassware made in America or England is more desirable.

China produced after the Civil War often has identifying marks on the back of each piece indicating its country of origin. Bone china made in England usually has a crown stamp on the back. If the pieces are bright in color — lime green or purple even — they are likely not vintage.

9. Limitations of Christmas China Patterns

Many manufacturers have lines of Christmas china. It tends to sell well throughout the year, but especially in September and October.

Some of the most popular Christmas china patterns are Spode’s Christmas Tree, which was first made in 1928; Lenox’s Holiday holly pattern (beware the gold leaf), and Johnson Brothers’ Merry Christmas, made from 1958 to 1995.

The Johnson pattern has a cozy Christmas scene on the middle of the plate, complete with a roaring fireplace.

If you find a set for 12 of any of these patterns, it’s still not likely you’ll bring in thousands of dollars, though a Johnson Merry Christmas dinner plate is fetching about $70 on Replacements.

The current value of a dinner plate of Spode’s Christmas Tree with gold trim is about $40. And Lenox’s Holiday holly plate could get nearly $70 through an antique dealer but Replacements had the dinner plate on sale in January 2022 for $40.

10. To eBay or Not to eBay Those Porcelain Dishes

If you sell on eBay you may get more money for your china or crystal than selling to an antique dealer who is going to resell your King Louis XV antique furniture or valuable china.

Obviously, you are then also the one who has to pack it (or pay someone else to pack it) and ship it so it arrives to the buyer in tip-top shape.

Customers buying on eBay have the right to refuse the product and ship it back at the seller’s expense if they say it arrived in worse condition than expected.

China Finders has been burned several times with eBay buyers who say the items they bought arrived chipped.

“We check it completely for chips when we buy it, when we sell it and when we ship it,” Larry Weitkemper said. But they still have to pay the cost to ship it back and refund the buyer’s money. Several times customers have shipped back different china, and once even a box of rocks instead of what they bought.

For China Finders, which sells hundreds of items on eBay each month, if a customer falsely claims the products weren’t in good condition once a month, it’s a cost of doing business.

But if you are selling a whole set of china or box of crystal goblets only once and a customer claims it arrived in poor condition then returns other items, your one shot at profiting off of Nana’s collection is shot.